We recently bought an additional 20 acres and with it we inherited a large infestation of Spotted knapweed. I have seen a plant here and there in other areas of our 45 acres so I knew it was not contained and we had to deal with this immediately. Much like I handled the research for the cool season grass and bindweeds, I did the same with this. Hopefully, this will help others who have problems with this invasive.
Spotted knapweed, Centaurea maculosa, was introduced to America via contaminated alfalfa and clover seed in the 1890s; it made its way to Canada in 1893. It is considered the “most problematic invasive species in North America” (Emery et al. 2005).
Aside from being an invasive species, which takes the place of native species who host our insects, spotted knapweed contributes to soil erosion, surface runoff, degradation of soil and water, reduces biodiversity, reduces wildlife habitat, and alters the ecosystem processes. Soil erosion and runoff are because the taproot and lateral root networks replace the connected systems of native plants.
While enjoying dry, disturbed sites, Spotted knapweed is not drought tolerant. In years of low rainfall, a population will decrease. Of course, there is an opposite effect in years of good moisture. This plant doesn’t seem too particular about the soil types and can adapt to most any type of soil.
The seeds are long-lived and durable because their hulls don’t easily decompose. In the soil, Zouhar (2001) has found that buried seeds can remain viable after 5 years. They can germinate in light or dark but rarely when they are 2” or more below the soil surface. There is a wide range of temperature under which they will germinate as well, from 44°F – 93°F (Schirman 1981). While the seeds might germinate under a shady canopy, the adult plants will not survive without full sun. Seeds are dispersed in a number of ways. If there is no external assistance, such as wind or mammal, the seed will remove itself from the seedhead and land 3-4 feet from the original plants; they do not overwinter on the plant (Zouhar 2001). Often they are carried to other locations by vehicles, water, shoes, and excrement of mammals and birds. Spotted knapweed seeds can remain viable 7-10 days after they are eaten by deer (Zouhar 2001).
The seeds of spotted knapweed germinate in 3 ways and each plant can produce seeds that fit each of the categories:
- Nondormant, meaning they germinate in the dark
- Light-sensitive, meaning they need exposure to red light to germinate
- Light-insensitive, meaning they do not germinate with red light
Here’s a scary fact. Schirman’s (1981) study had anywhere from 8 to 40 stems in a 5” hoop area, depending on the year and the placement of the hoop. He found that “survival of only about 0.1% of the seed produced is required to maintain the stand at the level we observed” (Schirman 1981). Egads!! Newly established populations will expand faster than older ones (Emery et al. 2005).
What would cause the plant to remain as a rosette or complete its life cycle in one year is not something I have found the answer to…yet. I can only think it has something to do with resource availability and competition.
Facts about Spotted Knapweed
- Short-lived perennial or biennial, living up to 3-9 years – this duo-classification is because the plant can live as a rosette for years before completing it life cycle or it can take only a single year. It’s plant specific.
- Stout taproot generates lateral shoots creating a fibrous mat of roots that can extend for several feet
- Plants regrow from the bud/root crown – this must be killed in order to kill the plant
- Produce 1,000 – 20,000 seeds per plant per year; precipitation is a major factor in this (NRCS, Sheley et al. 1998)
- About 90% of seeds are viable; can remain viable in the soil for 5-8 years
- Have spring and fall growth periods
- Older plants can have multiple rosettes and multiple blooming stems
- Is in the Asteraceae family
- Allelopathic – leaves and shoots exude cnicin.
Control based on Studies:
In general, to control spotted knapweed, management techniques need to be tailored to all life stages of the plant. Seems not a single treatment is the “magic bullet” and that a combination of treatments needs to be part of the protocol in order to control spotted knapweed. Two researchers found that knapweed would “increase to untreated level by the 6th year after single herbicide treatments” (MacDonald et al. 2013).
Hand pulling was necessary for mowing and herbicide treatments to be effective but was not sufficient on its own; other studies found that persistent hand pulling could decrease the knapweed population (MacDonald et al. 2013). A “substantial” reduction of spotted knapweed was made after three years of hand pulling coupled with mowing or herbiciding (MacDonald et al. 2013). It is imperative that when pulling that the root crown and top 3” of the taproot is removed (Panke et al. 2012). If there are flowers present at the time of pulling, these plants need to be removed from the site as they can continue to produce viable seed (Panke et al. 2012). Spotted knapweed has also been known to cause skin irritations in some folks so be sure to wear the proper protection on your hands, arms, and legs. Keep in mind that pulling can stir up seeds in the soil and cause germination. One would want to recheck the area in the same growing year.
The season of mowing is important. Mowing during the bud or flowering stage reduced the number of plants and reduced seed germination (Rinella et al. 2001). A single mowing when the plant was in bud or bloom was ineffective as well; two years of fall mowing did not have much effect but three years of fall mowing decreased the adult population (MacDonald et al. 2013, Rinella et al. 2001). There is no data available on how many years of mowing is needed to control an infestation (Panke et al. 2012).
This area had been mowed repeatedly during the summer, not for knapweed control. These are about ¼” diameter. I wonder if the stems in the photo below are indicative of the size of the stems of this plant in a previous year.
Burning was the least effective regardless of other treatments used in conjunction with it. Stands of spotted knapweed do not carry fire well (Emery et al. 2005). The fire needs to be hot enough to kill the root crown. According to Sheley and colleagues (1998), fires may actually create the environment where spotted knapweed can thrive rather than knocking it back as it might with other invasive plants. A literature review found that “in 80% of the studies prescribed burning either increased or had no effect on” knapweed (Emery et al. 2005). Those who did burn found it requires a very specific timing, frequency, and sufficient fuel loads (MacDonald et al. 2013). Early spring and fall burns were ineffective; fall burns actually increase germination success. Summer burns when the plant was in flower would reduce an infestation if the fire is hot enough. MacDonald and colleagues’ (2013) research found there were more seedlings after a fire that burned at less than 320°F, which this research considered a low-intensity fire. If there was a small patch, possibly a handheld propane torch would produce an intense enough fire to kill the plant. Annual summer burns were the most effective but it’s difficult to get the proper fuel loads to create a hot enough burn with annual burning. Alternating burn years increases plant’s reproduction.
Grazing can have a negative effect on the plant. The rosettes are tasty and nutritious but they are so low growing which makes it difficult for cattle to eat. Second-year plants are fibrous and not very tender. Sheep are the more appropriate grazers as they eat the first- and second-year plants without issue (Sheley et al. 1998). I found no studies that quantified this success.
Biological control seems to be well known for this plant but, I am skeptical of introducing insects that are not native to this area. One study shows that after the release of several species, the seed output was reduced and roots were damaged but the density of the plants were not altered (Rinella et al. 2001). There are 12 known insects species that are used for biocontrol; their purpose is to stress the plant with the hope the plants around it can outcompete it (Sheley et al. 1998). Caution is urged in using biocontrol as it means introducing a non-native insect. As I’m fond of saying, two non-natives don’t make a native.
There are a number of foliar herbicides that can provide effective treatment. Panke and colleagues (2012) listed many of these in the UW Extension publication. This document also notes the percent of effectiveness the various herbicides have on killing spotted knapweed. As we move through the process of getting rid of this infestation, I will post what we did and how successful or not our management techniques and combinations of techniques work.
Carpinelli, Michael. Spotted Knapweed. Plant Conservation Alliance’s Alien Plant Working Group Least Wanted.
Czarapata, Elizabeth J. 2005. Invasive Plants of the Upper Midwest. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
Davis, Edward S., Peter K. Fay, Timothy K. Chicoine, and Celestine A. Lacey. 1993. Persistence of Spotted knapweed seed in the soil. Weed Science 41: 57-61.
Emery, Sarah M. and Katherine L. Gross. 2005. Effects of timing of prescribed fire on the demography of an invasive plant, Spotted knapweed. Journal of Applied Ecology 42: 60-69.
Jacobs, James S. and Roger L. Sheley. 1998. Observation: Life history of spotted knapweed. Journal of Range Management 51(6): 655-673.
NRCS Pest Management – Invasive Plant Control. 2007. NRCS Conservation Practice Job Sheet MN-797.
MacDonald, Neil W., Laurelin M. Martin, Corey K. Kapolka, Timothy F. Botting, and Tami E Brown. 2013. Hand pulling following mowing and herbicide treatments increases control of Spotted knapweed. Invasive Plant Science and Management 6: 470-479.
Panke, Brendon, Ryan deRegnier, Mark Renz. 2012 Management of invasive plants in Wisconson: Spotted knapweed. University of Wisconsin Extension Publication A3924-13.
Rinella, Matthew J., James S. Jacobs, Roger L. Sheley, and John J. Borkowski. 2001. Spotted knapweed response to season and frequency of mowing. Journal of Range Management 54(1): 52-56.
Schirman, Roland. 1981. Seed production and spring seedling establishment of Diffuse and Spotted knapweed. Journal of Range Management 34(1): 45-47.
Sheley, Roger L., James S. Jacobs, and Michael F. Carpinelli. 1998. Distribution, biology, and management of Diffuse knapweed and Spotted knapweed. Weed Technology 12: 353-362.
Zouhar, Kris. 2001. Centaurea maculosa. In Fire Effects Information Ssytem, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station.